| Soybean aphid update
Christina DiFonzo, Entomology |
Last week I reported winged aphids on the buckthorn at my house near East Lansing. This week, those aphids are gone from my plants. All were winged in the last generation, and they flew away to their death in the woods surrounding my house.
However, Mary Gardiner, a graduate student working in the MSU Biocontrol Lab, found winged aphids on buckthorn on May 25, near the Bean and Beet research farm in Saginaw County. For those of you familiar with the area, the back edge of the farm is bordered by a “Rails to Trials” that is full of buckthorn. Bottom line – winged aphids are moving from buckthorn and looking for soybean!
|
| Speedier scouting of soybean suckers?
Christina DiFonzo, Entomology
| The current soybean aphid action threshold is based on number of aphids on whole plants, that is, 250 aphids per plant. But counting aphids can be time consuming, and it takes a good eye to see small individuals. Sure, university-types like myself have ample free time to sit around and gaze at plants. But for crop consultants, Extension educators and growers, an ideal aphid scouting method would be quick and easy so more fields can be covered in a shorter amount of time. That’s where “Speed Scouting” may be helpful.
Speed Scouting was developed by entomologists (Hodgson, McCornack, and Ragsdale) at the University of Minnesota. It classifies plants as either infested or uninfested, and then uses the total number of infested plants to make a decision. For those of you working in wheat, this is similar to the presence-absence scouting method used for determining spray applications for grain aphids. A speed scouting data sheet is included here. You can copy this sheet, or access the original from the University of Minnesota soybean aphid web site at: www.soybeans.umn.edu. This site also gives answers to Frequently Asked Questions about Speed Scouting.
Let me say up front that Speed Scouting is fairly new, and is not as well researched as the 250-per-plant action threshold currently recommended by Extension entomologists. Speed Scouting has not been validated in a year with widespread, heavy aphid pressure. In 2005, researchers across the Midwest will cooperate with the University of Minnesota to validate the method and compare it to the 250 threshold. Until Speed Scouting has more research behind it, using a threshold of 250 aphids per plant is the preferred, better-tested method. However, I recognize that during an aphid outbreak, there may not be the time or expertise to scout each field; Speed Scouting is at least better than no scouting. And compared to spraying on a calendar date as insurance, at least Speed Scouting will provide some guidance in making a decision, even if it needs further tweaking.
How does Speed Scouting work?
For the purposes of Speed Scouting, a plant with 40 or more aphids is considered to be “INFESTED.” A plant with low aphid numbers, (39 or fewer) is considered to be “UNINFESTED.” What if the plant has more than 40 aphids? STOP COUNTING! You have enough information to classify the plant as infested! In the words of Erin Hodgson, who developed this method, “This is what makes speed scouting speedy.”
Keeping in mind the definition of infested and uninfested – enter a field and pick a plant at random. Count the number of aphids on that plant (count only up to 40!) and classify that plant as infested or uninfested. Mark your result on the data sheet. I suggest using a minus sign [-] for uninfested plants and a plus sign [+] for infested plants. Choose a direction, walk 30 paces or rows, and sample another plant. Repeat the first step ten more times, to sample 11 plants, with 30 paces between each plant (fill in the first 11 spaces on the data sheet). Record the total number of infested plants in the first box and use the table on the right side of the sheet to make a decision.
§
If 6 or fewer of the 11 plants are infested, the aphid population in the field is low. You can STOP SAMPLING, because your decision is Do Not Treat. But return in seven to ten days to recheck the field!
§
If 11 of 11 plants are infested, aphid numbers are high. Your decision is again easy - STOP SAMPLING and spray the field within the next few days!
§
If between 7 to 10 plants are classified as infested, KEEP SAMPLING. You don’t have enough information yet to make a spray decision. Examine five more plants.
When sampling in increments of five plants, add the number of infested plants to the previous total. Use the table on the right side of the data sheet to make a decision. Keep sampling increments of five plants until you can make a decision OR until a total of 31 plants have been sampled. If after sampling 31 plants no decision was reached, STOP SAMPLING and come back in three to four days to resample. These are the most difficult fields, because aphids are present in moderate numbers, but the scout does not know if populations are increasing or decreasing (thus the need to return in several days).
What makes speed scouting speedy?
§
Less time spent counting. You never have to count more than 40 aphids per plant. For heavily infested plants, a simple glance is enough to classify it as a “+”.
§
Fields that are heavily infested or that are not infested are classified quickly, after looking at as few as 11 plants.
§
Data sheet is simple. Simply record and count minuses and pluses. No need to calculate the average number of aphids per plant with a calculator or cell phone.
Examples – use the Speed Scouting sheet to determine your decision. Answers are here
a. You sampled 11 plants and classified 4 plants as infested. What is your decision?
b. You sampled 11 plants and classified 9 plants as infested. What is your decision?
c. You examine 11 plants in a field, counting ALL the aphids on each plant (I don’t know why – you just like counting). Your totals are the following: 15, 66, 35, 68, 40, 128, 34, 92, 49, 55, 33. What is your decision using speed scouting?
d. Given the data in letter ‘c’, what is your decision using the 250 threshold?
e. You sampled 11 plants, but had to continue sampling two more times. The number of infested plants in each group is the following: 7 of 11; 4 of 5; and finally 2 of 5. After sampling a total of 21 plants, what is your decision using speed scouting?
f. Similar to question ‘e’- you sampled 11 plants, but had to continue sampling four more times. The number of infested plants in each group is the following: 10 of 11; 4 of 5; 4 of 5; 4 of 5; and finally 5 of 5. After sampling a total of 31 plants, what is your decision using speed scouting?
g. Why might it have taken you so long in Question ‘f’ to reach a decision?
|