Pheromone-based
management programs for codling moth and oriental fruit moth
Larry Gut, David Epstein and Peter McGhee
Entomology
|
Implementing a pheromone-based
control program
Factors to consider when implementing a pheromone-based control
program broadly consist of site selection, pheromone application,
product performance and monitoring. The best opportunity for control
is achieved where physical characteristics and environmental conditions
--topography, size and shape, canopy structure and wind -- allow
for uniform distribution of pheromone. For example, orchard sites
that are even canopied are better candidates for mating disruption
than sites with large numbers of missing trees. Using mating disruption
in a large, contiguous area is considered a better strategy than
in small, individual orchards. However, mating disruption can be
successfully combined with other management strategies for control
of moth pests in small orchards and where physical conditions are
less than optimum.
Experience teaches us that orchard borders require
extra attention when implementing mating disruption programs. Two
processes are thought to contribute to the development of border
infestations. First, mated females immigrate from adjacent orchards
that are not treated with pheromone. Second, it is suspected that
pheromone concentrations are lower on the borders than the interior
and so increases the likelihood of males locating females and mating
along borders.
Protecting borders
Several tactics can be used to protect orchard borders.
Additional pheromone can be applied to border trees or extended
into adjacent orchards if possible. This approach appears to be
most effective when initial pest densities are low. In orchards
that historically have a pest problem, it is best to treat borders
with insecticides in addition to applying more pheromone to the
borders or extending pheromone treatments into neighboring orchards.
An effective border treatment (insecticides or extra pheromone)
in most orchards would be an area equivalent to three or four rows
around the orchard perimeter or along the problem border. Treating
large contiguous areas with mating disruption is the best protection
against border damage, as this strategy decreases the amount of
border space relative to orchard interior.
Tips for success
Mating disruption, like any other control, is most effective
if the application is well timed, the rate is high enough, and coverage
is good. Effectiveness of mating disruption is reduced if dispensers
are applied late since this tactic provides no control once mating
has taken place. Most moths begin mating immediately upon emergence
into the orchard. Dispensers should be in place prior to the predicted
start of adult activity for the target pest. Coding moth and oriental
fruit moth are currently the principal candidates for control by
disruption in fruit orchards. Both pests have more than one period
of adult activity, the overwintering generation and at least one
summer generation flight. The best strategy for controlling codling
moth in apple and oriental fruit moth in peach is to apply dispensers
prior to the start of the first flight period. In contrast, targeting
only the late-season activity of oriental fruit moth is a viable
approach for using pheromones to manage this pest in apple.
For hand-applied disruption products, the rate
of application corresponds to the number of dispensers applied per
acre. Dispenser densities that can provide satisfactory control
for orchard pests at a reasonable cost range from 100 to 400 dispensers
per acre. The recommended application rate for most oriental fruit
moth disruption products is about 100 d/a or one per tree. An exception
to this is Isomate MRosso, a rope dispenser that has a recommended
application rate of 200 units per acre. To successfully disrupt
codling moth, the history of pest pressure within an orchard should
be considered when determining the number of dispensers to apply
per acre. Treat at the high end of the recommended rate if pest
pressure is moderate to high. Regardless of pest pressure, experience
over the past ten years strongly suggests that a minimum of 200
dispensers per acre is needed to result in worthwhile suppression
of codling moth mating. Good coverage for disrupting codling moth
or oriental fruit moth entails a more or less uniform distribution
of dispensers throughout the orchard. If two or more dispensers
per tree are applied, it is best to spread them out within the canopy.
Proper placement of dispensers within the tree
canopy can be a critical component of a pheromone-based control
program. Positioning dispensers in the upper portion of the canopy
generally provides the best chance of interfering with mate location.
However, good control of oriental fruit moth can be achieved by
placing dispensers in the middle of the canopy. In contrast, successful
mating disruption of codling moth requires placing dispensers within
two feet of the top of the canopy, but near foliage to protect
them from UV radiation and high temperatures. In orchards with canopy
heights greater than 10 feet, optimum placement of dispensers cannot
be achieved from the ground. A very good method for applying dispensers
is with the assistance of a pole and clip. Application entails pushing
a clip holding a dispenser onto a selected branch and leaving it
there when the pole is twisted and pulled away. It takes less than
2 hours to treat an acre of apples with this technique.
Monitoring target pest activity is difficult in
orchards treated with mating disruption products. Adult capture
in pheromone traps provides some measure of the effectiveness of
mating disruption. In pheromone treated orchards where control is
being achieved, moth catch in pheromone-baited traps should be very
low or shutdown completely. The rationale behind this measure of
effectiveness is that if males are incapable of finding a lure releasing
relatively large amounts of pheromone, then they are probably unable
to find female moths releasing much lower quantities of natural
pheromone. For oriental fruit moth, trap shutdown appears to be
a good indication that a high level of control is being achieved.
However, for codling moth, unacceptable levels of fruit injury often
occur where moth captures in traps are zero or very low. A pheromone
trap baited with a "high load" lure improves the utility of trapping
to determine the effectiveness of codling moth disruption. Another
option for monitoring disrupted orchards is to use traps baited
with a DA lure (Trécé Inc.). The DA lure releases a volatile that
is attractive to both female and male codling moth and is not impeded
or suppressed by pheromone-based mating disruption.
For all orchard pests, however, monitoring with
pheromone traps should not be relied on as a stand-alone method
for assessing the effectiveness of mating disruption. Trapping should
be used in conjunction with visual inspection of fruit for damage.
Concentrating visual examinations of fruit to the upper canopy,
orchard borders and susceptible varieties increases the chance of
early detection of fruit damage.
Pheromone formulations and dispensing systems
Various hand-applied dispensers are currently the most
widely used products for pheromone-based control of fruit pests. At
least four products are commercially available in the USA for control
of codling moth or oriental fruit moth: Isomate C Plus and CTT (Pacific
Biocontrol, Corp., Ridgefield, WA), CheckMate (Consep, Inc., Bend,
OR), NoMate (Scentry, Inc., Billings, MT) and Disrupt (Hercon, Inc.,
Emigsville, PA). Modifications to these formulations over the past
few years have focused on improved longevity and ease of application.
A new oriental fruit moth dispenser, Isomate MRosso, provided season-long
disruption in trials conducted in Michigan in 2002.
Hand-applied mating disruption formulations employ
either a single or multiple application strategy. These strategies
are designed to ensure the adequate release of pheromone throughout
the mating period of a target pest. All registered formulations
are sensitive to temperature, releasing more pheromone when it is
hot and less pheromone during cool periods. This variation in release
rates due to temperature difference makes it difficult to determine
the effective field life of a dispenser. Control problems have occurred
when dispensers have run out of pheromone earlier than expected,
leaving gaps when there is no pheromone dispensed. Dr. Jay Brunner
(WSU, Wenatchee, Washington) and other researchers have been evaluating
pheromone emission rates for various codling moth disruption products.
Among the products registered for use in the US, the two rope dispensers,
Isomate C Plus and CTT, had the highest and most consistent release
of pheromone. Consistent releases of pheromone were also provided
by the Checkmate CM and Disrupt CM dispensers, but at very low rates
per day. The NoMate CM dispenser released pheromone at a very high
rate initially, but ran out of pheromone after about 90 days. I
encourage you to discuss the expected field life of products to
ensure proper use and performance in the field with the dispenser
manufacturers or an extension specialist.
Pheromone can be formulated into tiny capsules
or beads and then applied through standard spray equipment on an
as needed basis. We have been testing microencapsulated formulations
manufactured by 3M Corporation or Suterra LLC. Sprayable pheromone
offers the opportunity to be readily incorporated into current programs
that include a number of sprays for diseases, insects and mites.
A sprayable product could be used on an as-needed basis rather than
as an expensive preventative control. The current use pattern for
sprayable pheromones is one to two applications per flight at a
high rate, generally greater than 10 gm AI/acre. Good control of
oriental fruit moth has been achieved using this strategy. However,
on-farm trials conducted in Michigan and in other states suggest
that high rates are not the most effective or economical way to
use sprayable pheromones. Significant rain events (> 0.5 inches)
wash off a portion of the microcapsules that contain the pheromone,
thus reducing the effectiveness of the treatment. Very low rates
(e.g., 2.5 gm AI/acre) appear to be as effective as high rates for
up to two weeks post-treatment. Frequent application of very low
rates of pheromone -- only a few grams per acre -- appears to be
the most economical and effective strategy for using sprayable pheromone
to manage oriental fruit moth. The label on this year's 3M Corporation
MEC-OFM sprayable formulation refers to "Low Rate Frequent Application
(LRFA)" and states, "Under this method the rate of application is
0.3 - 0.7 US fl. oz./acre (2 - 4 grams a.i./acre). Using this application
method, apply the product on a spray schedule of every 7 - 10 days
during the flight period." To date, both high rate and frequent
low rate sprayable pheromone strategies have proven to be substantially
less effective than hand-applied dispensers for codling moth control.
View dispensers
|