Some considerations when purchasing
your own weather equipment
Jeff Andresen
Agricultural Meteorology
Geography
|
Given the strong dependence of many IPM activities
on weather, there are a number of reasons for monitoring conditions
yourself. Perhaps most important is the fact that many weather variables
are highly variable across space, and are best measured where they
are to be used. There are many options when it comes to weather
monitoring, so before you spend money or time on a new system, ask
these critical questions to find equipment that is most economical
and suitable for your needs.
System considerations
The
first question should always be, "What are my real weather
monitoring needs?" For example, it really doesn't make sense
to purchase a temperature sensor with 0.1°F
accuracy when you will only be using the temperature data for simple
growing degree day calculations. Buyer or lease options on weather
systems typically include the following factors.
Sensor accuracy. Sensor costs increase quickly
for sensors with high accuracy. For many IPM applications, research-grade
measurements are not necessary.
Robustness. Will the system perform when
I really need it? Get a company's previous track record or advice
from professionals.
Simplicity. Simplicity can sometimes be
an asset when under other time constraints.
Number of variables measured. Do I need
more than precipitation and temperature? Multiple sensors may require
a larger, more expensive datalogger.
Degree of automation. How often can I afford
to take observations?
The method of telemetry. How do you plan
to retrieve the data? Options include everything from a manual read
of the sensor recorded on paper to radio, telephone, direct RS232
link to a personal computer, or even satellite.
In general, the greater the complexity and sophistication
of the system, the greater the cost. Similar to tools and other
purchases, there is a rule-of-thumb that applies here: "You
get what you pay for." Remember this especially if you
are looking for a system that needs to be working properly during
many seasons of use.
Other options beyond buying
For some users, there are a couple of other options available
besides purchasing your own equipment. Many states and some private
companies have networks of automated weather stations that collect
the information needed for IPM. If you are fortunate enough to be
located near one of these stations, this may be a cost-effective
option. Lastly, some companies are now offering localized weather
information derived from larger-scale meteorological and climatological
data. These so-called "off-site" data may be a less expensive
and adequate alternative for some users, depending on the sophistication
of the application. For most applications, however, data taken on
your farm is still the best strategy.
Deployment
As you prepare to put your new weather equipment
in the field, there are some important issues to consider. The first
is where to place the instruments. You likely only have one set
of instruments, so it is therefore critical to place them in a location
that will represent your orchard environment as closely as possible.
In general, greatest spatial variability in a given region will
be observed with leaf wetness, followed by precipitation, relative
humidity, and air temperature. Thus, if you have the resources for
extra sensors, the best investment would probably be in additional
leaf wetness sensors or precipitation gages.
In deciding where to place your instruments, a
rule-of-thumb is that the station should be at least four times
the height of the closest obstruction and away from any large paved
areas. Keep grass and weeds near the station trimmed. Also consider
the effects of microclimate. Microclimate refers to time-averaged
weather conditions over distances of less than half a mile, and
includes climate effects from the orchard level down to the microscopic
level. Endless combinations of characteristics such as crop canopy
structure, topography, and soil type can create unique microclimates.
Solar heating and airflow are the most significant factors determining
the microclimate in a particular area. For example, locations within
or very close to vegetation acting as a windbreak tend to be warmer
and more humid than locations in the open. Low-lying basin-shaped
areas tend to be prone to cold temperatures during the growing season
since cold air ponds there after moving from surrounding areas.
Besides serving as a location for a frost alarm for the first location
to reach the freezing mark on a frosty night, these sites should
generally be avoided for siting IPM instruments.
Try to select an area that
is:
§ Relatively
open with few obstructions to air flow in all directions;
§ Relatively
flat, to minimize the impact of cold air drainage or forced turbulence
around topographical obstacles;
§ Easily
accessible to you night and day; and
§ Close
enough to an orchard to place a leaf wetness sensor if one is available
with your system.
In choosing a site to meet your needs, remember
that it may be virtually impossible to meet all of these criteria.
Try to minimize the number of overall potential problems.
Temperature and precipitation
The two weather variables most commonly monitored
by growers are air temperature and precipitation. For precipitation,
try to site your gage on level ground away from any overhead obstructions.
Typical installation height is 3 to 4 feet above the ground. When
installing on a post, make sure that the opening of the gage is
above the top of the post. Keep the gage level, especially if using
tipping bucket-type rain gages. When the gage is in use, periodically
check for any cracks, insects, accumulated dust or bird droppings.
For placement of temperature sensors in the field,
there is one special rule. Never allow the sensor to be directly
exposed to the sun or open sky, as such exposure can lead to erroneous
or misleading measurements. If at all possible, use a screened or
ventilated shield or enclosure if one is available for this purpose.
By convention, the sensor should be placed at a height 5 to 6 feet
above the ground surface. Avoid installation near paved areas, on
walls of buildings or other artificial heat sources, or near low
places where water tends to pond after rain.
Relative humidity and leaf
wetness
Relative humidity and leaf wetness measurements
are of special importance, as one or both are typically needed for
monitoring plant disease risk. For relative humidity, placement
in the field is fairly easy. For many sensors and automated systems,
the relative humidity probe is combined with a temperature sensor,
and the entire probe is installed in a shielded enclosure. For leaf
wetness, however, there are few set rules, as there are no agreed
upon standards for measurement of the variable.
The first issue is what type of sensor to choose.
Options range from a rope wick connected to a mechanical recorder
to an electronic grid plate across which resistance can be measured.
For simplicity and automation, many users choose an electronic grid.
Some users prefer to have the sensor professionally coated with
a latex paint. Paint causes the sensor to be physically more representative
of a plant leaf and tends to spread out any water droplets over
the surface, making the painted grid generally more sensitive to
dew formation. For leaf wetting events associated with rainfall,
painted and unpainted grids respond similarly. Placement of your
leaf wetness sensor in the field may vary greatly depending on crop
and disease. In contrast to other meteorological measurements that
are taken in more open locations, the best bet with leaf wetness
sensors is placement within the plant canopy. While there is no
standard, some plant pathologists recommend placement in an apple
canopy on the north side of the tree above the first scaffold about
midway between the tree trunk and the drip line. Past research indicates
a consistent response with the plate sloped at a 20-degree angle
downwards towards the north.
Upkeep and maintenance
After your weather system is in the field, remember that
upkeep and maintenance of the system and its sensors are essential
for it to provide useful information for your IPM program. Plan
to check sensors at least once and preferably twice per year. Follow
the manufacturer's guidelines closely for checking operation of
the system and maintaining calibration. In general, the more sophisticated
the sensor or device, the greater the need for periodic checks.
For example, electronic relative humidity probes can lose calibration
relatively quickly, and should be checked carefully at least once
per year, and replaced if necessary. In contrast, manually read
sensors such as liquid in glass thermometers and rain gages can
provide years of service with minimal care. Many problems with sensors
are spontaneous and easily detectable. Other problems, such as sensor
drift, may be more difficult to detect without regular inspection
or comparative analysis of the data from a second, nearby data source.
Some commercial sources
of weather instruments and equipment
The accompanying table is a short list of some
vendors who either manufacture or sell a variety of weather monitoring
equipment. It is by no means complete, but provides a range of offerings
regarding instrument accuracy, durability, and cost.
|
Company
|
Phone
|
E-mail
|
|
Belfort
Instrument Company
727
South Wolfe Street
Baltimore,
MD 21231
|
410.342.2626
|
www.belfort-inst.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Campbell
Scientific, Inc.
815
West 1800 North
Logan,
UT 84321
|
435.753.2342
|
www.campbellsci.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Davis
Instrument
4701
Mount Hope Dr.
Baltimore,
MD 21215
|
800.368.2516
|
www.davisontheweb.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Forestry
Suppliers, Inc.
205
West Rankin St.
P.O.
Box 8397
Jackson,
MS 39284-8397
|
601.354.3565
|
www.forestry-suppliers.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Met
One Instruments, Inc.
1600
Washington Blvd.
Grants
Pass, OR 97526
|
972.412.4747
|
www.metone.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Onset
Computer Corp.
P.O.
Box 3450
Pocasset,
MA 02559-3450
|
800.564.9100
|
www.onsetcomp.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Qualimetrics,
Inc.
1165
National Drive
Sacramento,
CA 95834
|
916.928.1000
|
www.qualimetrics.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
R.M.
Young Comp.
2801
Aero Park Dr.
Traverse
City, MI 49686
|
231.946.3980
|
www.traverse.com/commerce/rmyoung
|
|
|
|
|
|
Scientific
Sales, Inc.
P.O.
Box 6725
Lawrenceville,
NJ 08648
|
800.788.5666
|
sales@scientificsales.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Spectrum
Technologies, Inc.
23839
W. Andrew Road
Plainfield,
IL 60544
|
800.248.8873
|
specmeters@aol.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Weathertools.com
5911
Broadway
San
Antonio, TX 78209
|
800.826.5708
|
WeatherTools.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
Vaisala,
Inc
100
Commerce Way
Woburn,
MA 01801-1068
|
781.933.4500
|
www.vaisala.com
|
|